Impact of extrinsic motivation on intrinsic motivation
Motivation can be simply defined as the things that induce us to take certain actions or behave in a certain way. It is the why or the reason that drives a person towards a desired goal.
The reasons can be categorized into something that is within us i.e. intrinsic / internal motivation, or something that is external to us i.e. extrinsic / external motivation.
Internal motivation in performing a task occurs when the task in itself is experienced as rewarding and there is no need for any external reward before it is performed. Examples are love of the task, self-satisfaction, sense of achievement, relaxation purpose, etc.
External motivation in performing a task occurs when the task is performed because of an external reward. Examples are praise, recognition, money, stickers, grades, material rewards, etc.
Motivation can be seen as a continuum from being externally driven to becoming more internally driven. All of us start off in life being externally driven. Remember how many children are bribed with sweets or stickers, and do things to get praise from adults. But as we mature and our material needs become more satisfied, we become more internally driven. Though intrinsic motivation is generally accepted as being better as it is within the internal control of the person, external motivation is useful in helping a person initially to get on a task when he does not feel intrinsically motivated to do so.
However, the excessive use of external motivation might have detrimental effects. This has been shown in research or experiments that examine the effects of external reward on an internally motivated task.
The 1973 paper "Undermining children's intrinsic interest with extrinsic rewards: A test of the overjustification hypothesis" by M Lepper, D Green & R Nisbett, reported an interesting experimental observation. During children's free-play time, a fun drawing activity was introduced. They observed the children playing and selected those children who appeared to find intrinsic satisfaction in drawing. These children were placed under three different conditions.
Condition 1: "Good Player" certificate was shown to some of the children, and asked if they would like to draw to win the certificate.
Condition 2: Some children were given the opportunity to simply engage in drawing and the children were given the "Good Player" certificate unexpectedly.
Condition 3: Some children simply drew without expecting or receiving any reward.
Two weeks later, all these children were again allowed to engage in the drawing activity. The result was interesting. It was found that the children who chose to draw for the reward showed less interest in drawing, and also when the reward was withdrawn, these children simply stopped drawing. Children in the other two conditions showed no significant change in their interest in drawing. The result seems to suggest that the external reward of a "Good Player" certificate destroyed the original intrinsic motivation for drawing.
In 1975, EL Deci reported his research findings in the paper "Intrinsic motivation", that when people were given rewards for pursuing intrinsically satisfying goals, decreased motivation was the result. The result seems to suggest that if people already enjoy what they are doing, giving rewards for their engaging in this activity can act as a deterrent in continuing with that activity.
These two reports seem to suggest that external rewards can destroy intrinsic motivation. There is therefore the danger of "overjustification" in our enthusiasm to motivate good performance through rewards.
What are the lessons that we can learn in motivating our children, students or subordinates? Suggestions are:
1. Develop intrinsic motivation for tasks, e.g. by providing a safe environment for them to pursue their own interests without undue interference.
2. Encourage intrinsic motivation for tasks e.g. providing opportunities for sharing of work and of the personal satisfaction gained.
3. Provide external rewards sparingly, and without giving expectations for it.
References:
1. http://www.succezz.com/S2/ForbiddenPsychologicalTactics.html
2. http://www.succezz.com/S2/Confessionsofawebsitecopywriter.html
3. http://www.succezz.com/S2/MotivateYourWayToSuccess.html
Jacob Gan PhD (Michigan) has more than 20 years of teaching experience in a university and 8 years of business/industrial experience after graduation. He writes for succezz.com, JacobGan.com, JacobEducation.com, DemystifyCancer.com, understanding-orchids.com, motivate2success.com and JacobLearning.com. He hosts Jacob.TheeLearningcentre.com, an elearning portal
Related Articles:
Display Well Launches First, End-to-End Exhibit and Sign Design and Production Center: Company Enables Creation of High-Quality Portable Displays
Display Well (www.displaywell.com), the only company that enables complete design and production of portable signs and small-scale exhibits from concept to delivery, announced today the launch of its one-stop, online design center. For every short-staffed, budget-strained, time-crunched organization that, nevertheless, still needs to make a promotional impact, the days of multiple yellow page searches, vendor agreements and trips to the corner copy center are over.
Toshiba Matsushita Display Technology Selects Kinaxis RapidResponse
Response management solution to improve operations performance amid constant business volatility and continuous product innovation.
Jewelry Display Lighting
Linear strips offer an excellent source of jewelry display lighting They combine a concealed physical presence with an evenly distributed light source that works well for showcasing entire collections of jewelry laid out on pedestals or cloth backings
Fortune Market Media, Inc. Announces the "D" to be Removed From its Stock Symbol and it will Resume Trading Under its Original Symbol FTMM on December
Fortune Market Media Inc. announces that after successfully completing its reorganization of its capital structure and being assigned a transitional Symbol FTMMD on November 13, 2007 by NASDAQ for 20 business days, it will resume trading under it?s original symbol: FTMM on Monday December 10, 2007.
POS Cash Drawer - Using Touch Screen For Your Business
You have to admit, long gone are the days when the sales in a store were made by the person behind the counter by writing the product sold and the price in a notebook. The need for accurate bookkeeping, the detailed overview of the company's business, the products sold and the amounts of money obtained. Using a POS system has many benefits, as it allows for a more accurate and precise method of doing business, of selling products and services. There are many types of systems available and it is up to you what kind of POS system you buy for your company. There are more advanced models, that can be linked in a network and that can be centered in a computer based network, that are suitable for larger companies, but there are also more simple ...
Art Therapist Myriam Reynolds Set to Display First Gallery Showing May 2 Portion of Proceeds to Benefit Denver Children's Home
The spirit of healing will soon be seen as new coming artist and avid philanthropist, Myriam Reynolds, prepares to dazzle and delight art patrons on May 2 with her first collection at Now ArtSpace located in Denver, Colo.
VIZ Pictures and NCM Fathom Debut Live Action Japanese Feature Death Note on the Big Screen: Special Two-Night Event will be Shown May 20th and 21s
DEATH NOTE, a live-action Japanese feature event shows that the pen is mightier than the sword in a special two-night event at more than 300 theatres on May 20th and 21st at 7:30 p.m. local time. This unique theatre event (English dubbed) brings to life the popular Japanese manga series written by Tsugumi Ohba and will feature an exclusive behind-the-scenes look at the creation of this breakthrough live action production, an in-depth interview with Director Shusuke Kaneko and a unique look at the talent behind the Death Note characters.
Retail Display Lighting
Retail Display Lighting constitutes a very complex science and generally requires the help of a lighting designer or display lighting expert who can help you choose the right fixtures, bulb types, voltage settings, and lighting controls for your store Any online query will quickly produce an endless array of retail display light fixtures that can quickly overwhelm your senses and your pocket book if you are unsure of what you need
Platform-A to Manage Virgin Mobile WAP Banner Ad Inventory : Virgin Mobile will continue to use Third Screen Media's mobile ad serving platform
AOL and Virgin Mobile USA announced today that Platform-A will serve as the exclusive display advertising and sales partner for Virgin Mobile USA?s WAP banner inventory. Under the terms of an agreement between the parties, the Platform-A sales force will manage Virgin Mobile USA?s WAP banner inventory, while fully leveraging Platform-A?s Third Screen Media mobile ad serving platform. Third Screen Media (http://www.thirdscreenmedia.com) is Platform-A?s mobile ad serving platform and network.
Big Screen Entertainment Centers - Dress Up That Tv In Your Living Or Media Room
Americans prefer large and in your face types of entertainment Most of what we receive, when it comes to this effect, derives from our modern high tech television screens, which spew forward dramatic images into our living rooms
Display Web Page ThumbShots without Hosting Images
What Are ThumbShots?Thumbshots are screen shot previews of web sites which allow your web site visitors to preview a link before clicking on it.Who Uses Thumbshots? Thumbshots can be used by any web site which links to another website in order to enhance the surfer experience.
Motorola RAZR maxx V6: Same Old Same Old
Motorola has been known to produce quality slim phones. Unfortunately more often than not quality phones only revolve around looks and appeal. It looks good aesthetically but not fully functional. RAZR models have limited features and instead focus on design and body construction.
Wholesale Sunglasses Company Announces Free Display Box and Volume Discounts
CTSwholesalesunglasses.com today introduced free sunglass display boxes and volume based discounts for the retailers.
Americans' Sickness Over Health Care Hits The Big Screen
After months of waiting, the country will finally get its opportunity to weigh in on the movie "Sicko" by controversial film producer Michael Moore. Posture and Vitality expert, Aaron Parnell, agrees with Moore and the documentary's focus on the deficiencies in health care delivery and financing for Americans. In addition, he says socialized medicine in America could be a good idea IF American people thought and made mindful lifestyle choices like the French, the Canadians, or the Brits.
LCD Or Plasma ? Which Is Best For Your Digital Signage Display?
In the world of digital signage there is a debate about which display option is best ? LCD or plasma
There are many factors summarized here, including performance and cost, that will determine whether you choose LCD or plasma for your digital signage display